Article 26(Request for Statutory Interpretation) #
(1) Where the head of a central administrative agency has a question as to the interpretation of a statute in the course of implementing and enforcing the statutes or regulations, such as the receipt of a question requiring legal ruling from the head of a local government or a civil petitioner, he or she shall request a statutory interpretation from an agency specializing in statutory interpretation under Article 40 (3) of the Framework Act on Administration (in cases of the interpretation of statutes or regulations related to civil affairs, commercial affairs, criminal affairs, administrative litigations, and State compensation, statutes or regulations under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Justice, and penalty provisions of other statutes or regulations, referring to the Ministry of Justice; and in cases of the interpretation of all other administration-related statutes or regulations, referring to the Ministry of Government Legislation; hereinafter referred to as "statutory interpretative agency") make a statutory interpretation. <Amended on Dec. 1, 2021>
(2) Where the head of a central administrative agency intends to request the interpretation of any statutes or regulations under the jurisdiction of another central administrative agency under paragraph (1), he or she shall first hear the opinion of the central administrative agency having jurisdiction over the relevant statutes or regulations.
(3) The head of a local government shall request the head of a central administrative agency having jurisdiction over the relevant statutes or regulations to interpret the statutes or regulations and receive his or her reply thereto before requesting a statutory interpretative agency to make a statutory interpretation.
(4) Where the head of a local government deems that the details of a reply received under paragraph (3) is unclear (including where there is no de facto opinion in the reply) or has an objection to such details, the head may request a statutory interpretation from a statutory interpretative agency, appending the details of the reply thereto: Provided, That if the head of a central administrative agency having jurisdiction over the relevant statutes or regulations fails to reply within one month (such period may be extended only once by up to one month, notifying the special grounds for the delay, if any), despite the receipt of the request for a statutory interpretation under paragraph (3), the details of a reply need not be appended. <Amended on Jun. 27, 2023>
(5) Where a statutory interpretative agency is in receipt of a request for statutory interpretation to which a reply by the head of a central administrative agency having no de facto opinion is appended under the body of paragraph (4) or a request for statutory interpretation to which no reply by the head of a central administrative agency is appended under the proviso to the same paragraph, it shall request the head of the central administrative agency having jurisdiction over the relevant statutes or regulations to provide his or her opinion, and the head of the central administrative agency in receipt of such request shall send the reply as requested to the statutory interpretative agency within 10 days from the date of receipt of such request (such period may be extended only once by up to one month, notifying the special ground for the delay, if any).
(6) Where the head of a central administrative agency or the head of a local government requests a statutory interpretation under paragraph (2) or (4), he or she shall notify the head of a central administrative agency having jurisdiction over the relevant statutes or regulations.
(7) Where a civil petitioner has an objection to a statutory interpretation made by the head of a central administrative agency having jurisdiction over the relevant statutes or regulations, he or she may entrust the head to request a statutory interpretation from a statutory interpretative agency or may directly request such interpretation from such agency, appending the statutory interpretation made by the head, as prescribed by Ordinance of the Prime Minister: Provided, That this shall not apply where the Minister of Justice has made a statutory interpretation of statutes or regulations related to civil affairs, commercial affairs, criminal affairs, administrative litigation, or State compensation, or statutes or regulations under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Justice. <Amended on Dec. 1, 2021; Jun. 27, 2023>
(8) Upon receipt of a request for statutory interpretation from a civil petitioner under paragraph (7), the head of a central administrative agency having jurisdiction over the relevant statutes or regulations shall request a statutory interpretative agency to make a statutory interpretation without delay, appending his or her opinion, if there is any to be added to the details replied to the civil petitioner (including the civil petitioner's question about the relevant statutes or regulations): Provided, That in any of the following cases, he or she need not request a statutory interpretation, and shall notify the relevant civil petitioner thereof, specifying the grounds therefor: <Amended on Aug. 13, 2019; Dec. 1, 2021>
1. Where it fails to meet any of the requirements for requesting statutory interpretation under paragraph (7);
2. Where any established judicial precedent exists or a statutory interpretative agency has already made a statutory interpretation;
3. Where it is a matter related to finding detailed facts;
4. Where any administrative appeal or administrative litigation is pending or where such procedure is complete;
5. Where it is a matter of whether a detailed disposition or act already made or conducted is illegal or unreasonable;
6. Where it is a matter of whether the relevant statutes or regulations are unconstitutional or contrary to the upper statutes or regulations;
7. Where it is a matter related to a policy of a central administrative agency having jurisdiction over the relevant statutes or regulations and it is necessary to make a decision through judgment on policy or consultation among central administrative agencies;
8. Where statutes or regulations subject to interpretation are not specified;
9. Where it is not deemed necessary to make a statutory interpretation because a request for statutory interpretation is based on a false premise, such as there is no correlation between the grounds or reasons for requesting the statutory interpretation and the provisions of the relevant statutes or regulations for which such request is made;
10. Where the provisions of the relevant statutes or regulations are so clear that the interpretation thereof is unnecessary;
11. Other cases where it is deemed obviously unnecessary for the reasons similar to those specified in subparagraphs 1 through 10.
(9) When a statutory interpretative agency receives a request for statutory interpretation directly from a civil petitioner under paragraph (7), it shall immediately notify such fact to the head of a central administrative agency having jurisdiction over the relevant statutes or regulations. <Amended on Dec. 1, 2021>
(10) Upon receipt of a request for statutory interpretation under paragraph (1), (4), (7), or (8), a statutory interpretative agency may request supplementation to the head of a central administrative agency, the head of a local government, or a civil petitioner who has requested the statutory interpretation, if deemed necessary. <Amended on Aug. 13, 2019; Dec. 1, 2021>
(11) A statutory interpretative agency shall return a request for statutory interpretation, in any of the following cases: <Newly Inserted on Aug. 13, 2019; Dec. 1, 2021>
1. Where a request for statutory interpretation fails to meet the requirements for requesting statutory interpretation under paragraphs (1) through (4) and (7);
2. Where a request for statutory interpretation falls under paragraph (8) 2 through 11;
3. Where a request for supplementation under paragraph (10) is not complied with.
[This Article Wholly Amended on Oct. 5, 2010]